Bankrate.com advises you to buy gold, even though it is just coming off its historic high. Gold has its benefits as an investment, but it also screams “Buyer beware!”
Bankrate.com cites CMC Markets trading strategist Ashraf Laidi, who has over half of his asset allocation in gold and offers 6 reasons why now is a great time to buy gold:
- Real interest rates (interest rates minus inflation) are down globally. Result: Gold yields a better return than stocks or bonds.
- The declining dollar. Gold rises when currency falls.
- The ETF effect. With the introduction of exchange-traded funds in 2003, investors can now buy into the gold market with the click of a mouse. What’s more, it’s less risky than investing directly in gold mining. Two of the most popular gold ETFs are StreetTracks Gold Trust (GLD) and iShares COMEX Gold Trust (IAU). “The convenience by which individual investors can get in on the gold rally is propelling the rally itself,” Laidi says.
- International rally. Gold is rallying worldwide, not just against the U.S. dollar but other currencies as well. Every time the Fed cuts interest rates to contend with the impact of the credit crisis, gold becomes more attractive.
- Increased fabrication: Emerging economies in China, India, Asia and the Middle East are boosting demand for gold jewelry.
- Political and economic uncertainty: When fears arise as they did post-Sept. 11, the enduring value of the world’s oldest currency takes on a new luster.
Laidi isn’t necessarily wrong in his analysis, but he’s not giving the whole picture, either. For example, he points to the “ETF effect,” but just because it is easier now to invest in gold and gold stocks through ETFs doesn’t mean it’s a good idea; there are other factors to weigh.
Hedging Inflation
Contrary to popular belief, gold is a very poor hedge against inflation. A Bloomberg article from last October addresses this misconception:
“Gold is often described as an inflation hedge, but in fact there are few instances in the past 20 years when gold has moved in sync with either core or headline inflation,” says James Gutman, a London-based commodity economist at Goldman Sachs International. Thus, gold “should not be used as an inflation hedge,” he says.
Gold reached a record high of $850 an ounce in January 1980. If since then the spot price of bullion kept pace with U.S. inflation as measured by the consumer-price index, gold would now be selling for $2,119.84. Instead, it stood at $732.05 in London trading yesterday, only about a third of what it should be if it were truly an effective inflation hedge.
Investors seeking protection from inflation would have been better off in the U.S. stock market. On Jan. 30, 1980, the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index stood at 115.20. Adjusting the index to compensate for the increase in the CPI since then would put it at 287.30 today. Yet on Oct. 3, the S&P 500 closed at 1539.59, more than five times the inflation-break-even level.
Gold reflects market sentiment about inflation. When investors are acutely aware of inflation, they may buy gold as a hedge. But in the 80s, the example cited above, there was less panic about inflation - and without that driving fear, demand for gold wasn’t high enough to keep pace with inflation over the past two decades. Without demand to provide upward pressure on prices, gold simply didn’t keep up with inflation.
Hedging a Weak Dollar
Yes, the dollar has weakened as the Fed cut rates. But foreign exchange is volatile, and many analysts are now pointing out that the dollar is oversold - that is, investors have been trading the dollar down more than it should be.
Concurrently, commodities may have been traded higher than where they should be. USA Today notes:
Soaring energy prices can fuel inflation, and gold rises 90% of the time when oil does, says Frank Holmes, CEO of U.S. Global Investors. Oil soared above $110 a barrel Thursday, a record.
Still, gold may have come too far, too fast, Holmes says. Gold prices correlate closely with oil and move in the opposite direction of the dollar.
“According to our models, the dollar is overextended on the down side, and oil is overextended on the up side,” Holmes says. That’s why he’s looking for a short-term correction in gold prices.
When the dollar recovers, gold prices will slow its ascent. But if you believe the dollar will continue to be weak, then you can hedge against this weakness by investing in international stocks through mutual funds or ETFs, or even put your money into foreign currency-denominated CDs. There’s no need to buy into a volatile commodity just because the dollar is weak.
Gold Is Costly, and Gold ETFs Are Too
Gold bars and coins are considered collectibles by the IRS, and any realized gains are taxed as income rather than at capital gains - a tax rate of up to 28% versus a capital gains rate of up to 15%. Moreover, if you invest in gold as a physical good rather than through gold stocks or ETFs, you’ll have to pay for transportation (which can be costly since gold is heavy) and for storage (which can also be expensive if you want security).
If you do invest in ETFs, you’re not out of the woods. Street Tracks Gold Shares (GLD) trades like a stock, relieves you from the cost of transport and storage, but is taxed like real gold bars and coins. For most people, this means you’d pay about twice as much in taxes as you would for a stock ETF on the same realized gain.
Political and Economic Uncertainty?
Gold has historically been a means of securing value in turbulent times. But it’s economic uncertainty that makes gold a dangerous investment now. One reason that gold experienced its sharp fall last week is that hedge funds that had invested in the commodity sold off gold in order to cover other positions - they have to get money from somewhere. As banks tighten lending requirements for investors who are trading on borrowed money, more funds may be forced to sell off gold positions, thus driving prices down.
In fact, contrary to what Laidi asserted, global demand for gold has decreased for the past few years. India, for example, is shying away from gold because it’s too expensive for fabrication. Gold prices have not been driven up by global demand, but rather by professional investors and speculators. These are the same people that will jump off the gold bandwagon as soon as it suits them - leaving the amateurs in the dust as gold faces a correction.
For the Right Reasons, at the Right Time
This doesn’t mean you should shun gold. It is indeed an asset that has low correlation to most other asset classes. It may provide the zag to keep your portfolio afloat when stocks, bonds, and real estate all zig.
You should think carefully about why you’re investing in gold, especially since prices are still relatively high. Don’t rush in based on recent performance. Now that even mainstream media are touting gold as a “safe” investment, newcomers are probably too late to the party and just in time for a correction. Instead, carefully plan how you will enter the market.
You should also choose the appropriate allocation for your portfolio and situation. I would never take Laidi’s example and put over half my money in gold. He may have a good reason for that allocation. Consult with a financial expert before making significant changes to your portfolio.
How to Invest in Gold
Some resources on investing in gold, whether through physical bullions or other vehicles:
- “Methods of investing in gold” at Wikipedia (yes, Wikipedia). This article gives a good rundown of various investment methods as well as some major issues to consider when investing in gold.
- “Want to Add Some Glitter to Your Portfolio?” at Morningstar. This article lists major mutual funds and ETFs that offer gold exposure, as well as a comparison of investing in gold mutual funds versus investing in gold ETFs.
- “How to invest in gold” at the World Gold Council. The source isn’t as biased as you think it’d be. WGC provides a lot of details on the different ways of investing in gold, as well as a brief list of questions you should ask yourself before investing in gold.
Gold is just like any other investment - avoid chasing returns, keep your emotions in check, and always do your research. Ultimately, you should think long, think hard, and don’t trust what the news media says unless you can verify it yourself.